Understanding Attachment Styles: How Four Types Expanded to More Than 12

Understanding Attachment Styles: How Four Types Expanded to More Than 12

Attachment theory is one of the most influential frameworks in modern psychotherapy, and it continues to evolve as researchers refine and expand its concepts. An attachment style is a pattern that shapes how we seek closeness, respond to emotional needs, and behave in close relationships. Although the classifications have changed over time, one principle remains consistent: attachment can profoundly influence our behavior and interactions with the people closest to us.

This article explores the development of attachment theory, explains why some models describe four attachment styles while others identify more than 12, and provides an overview of the four basic adult attachment styles.

The Evolution of Attachment Theory

What Is Attachment Theory?

The groundwork for attachment theory was laid by English psychiatrist and psychoanalyst John Bowlby. He understood attachment as a child’s instinctive drive to seek closeness to a significant adult when feeling threatened or uncomfortable. At the heart of this drive is a fundamental need for security. In adult relationships, attachment reflects our basic biological need to form a deep connection with another person.

Attachment styles begin to form in early childhood. For healthy emotional and social development, a child needs at least one secure bond with a significant adult.

Mary Ainsworth and the Strange Situation Experiment

In the 1960s, Bowlby’s colleague, developmental psychologist Mary Ainsworth, conducted the “Strange Situation” experiment, which became a landmark study of attachment. During the experiment, children between the ages of 1 and 2 were observed with their mothers in an unfamiliar room filled with toys.

Researchers then introduced different situations, such as having the mother leave the room and, in some cases, leaving the child with a stranger. They observed how each child responded to the mother’s presence, departure, and return. They also focused on whether the child maintained a connection with the mother during her absence and showed interest in exploring the surrounding environment.

These observations initially led researchers to identify three main attachment styles:

  • Secure
  • Anxious-avoidant, insecure
  • Anxious-resistant, insecure

A fourth style, known as disorganized/disoriented attachment, was later added by Ainsworth’s students. They had noticed that some children displayed unpredictable behavior and a mixture of coping strategies that did not fit neatly into the original three categories.

How Attachment Theory Was Applied to Adult Relationships

In the late 1980s, American psychologists Cindy Hazan and Philip Shaver expanded attachment theory by applying it to adult romantic relationships. They found that attachment patterns between romantic partners often resembled those observed between parents and children.

Building on the four styles identified in parent-child relationships, Hazan, Shaver, and their colleagues described four parallel adult attachment styles. These adult patterns closely align with the original attachment types developed through the work of Bowlby and Ainsworth.

Why Are There Four Attachment Styles—or More Than 12?

Today, psychologists use several different classifications of attachment styles. American psychologist Patricia Crittenden, a student of Ainsworth, has identified more than 12 types. Her model begins with three primary patterns—secure, anxious, and avoidant attachment—and divides them into more nuanced types and complex strategies.

In other words, the difference between four and more than 12 attachment types reflects different levels of detail within different classification systems. Despite these developments, the four basic adult attachment styles described by Hazan and Shaver remain the most widely used. The following overview introduces these four styles, while subsequent articles will explore each one in greater depth.

The 4 Basic Attachment Styles

1. Secure Attachment: “I’m OK, You’re OK”

In a romantic relationship, someone with a secure attachment style is open and sincere with their partner and is not afraid to show love. They tend to have a flexible mindset, communicate effectively, and handle conflict constructively.

Key pattern: A person with secure attachment is generally comfortable with both emotional closeness and their own sense of self.

2. Preoccupied-Anxious Attachment: “I’m Not OK, but You’re OK”

People with a preoccupied-anxious attachment style crave emotional closeness but often feel that they are not receiving enough of it. They may pay close attention to their partner’s needs—sometimes excessively—and may struggle with jealousy or separation anxiety.

Key pattern: Their greatest fear is being abandoned by their partner, which can intensify their need for reassurance and closeness.

3. Fearful-Avoidant Attachment: “I’m Not OK, and You’re Not OK”

A fearful-avoidant attachment style can create a relationship that feels like an emotional roller coaster. People with this pattern may become anxious when they sense distance from their partner, yet pull away when their partner tries to move closer.

Key pattern: They may hold two conflicting beliefs at the same time: “Nobody needs me” and “I need nobody.” This tension can lead to alternating efforts to seek and avoid closeness.

4. Dismissing-Avoidant Attachment: “I’m OK, You’re Not OK”

People with a dismissing-avoidant attachment style place a high value on autonomy, sometimes to the point of becoming emotionally distant from their partner. They tend to suppress their feelings, although those emotions may occasionally emerge in bursts of irritation or anger.

Key pattern: They may show little concern for their partner’s needs and generally do not expect other people to meet their own emotional needs.

Can You Have More Than One Attachment Style?

Do any of these attachment styles resonate with you? Human relationships are complex. Although one style often predominates and may shape your choice of partner and your relationship dynamics, elements of other styles can also appear. Having traits associated with more than one attachment style is entirely normal.

In the next article, you’ll find a test designed to help you identify your dominant attachment style.


Follow us on social media 👇


Он будет закрыт в 0 секунд